Staging as a Guide for Treatment Selection
The staging system serves as a
guide to
therapeutic options; however, neither
the present classification nor any other
could be absolute in this regard. In
terms of conventional treatment,
surgery is the primary treatment option
for all patients with non-small cell lung
cancer with stages IA, IB, IIA and IIB
disease who are physiologically able to
undergo thoracic operation and the required
sacrifice of lung tissue. Selected patients
with stage IIIA tumors are also candidates
for surgery, usually in combination with
neoadjuvant and adjuvant treatment. The
potential for complete resection of all
known tumor is a key element and limiting
factor. Controversy exists over the options
for surgery in patients with evidence of
ipsilateral mediastinal and subcarinal
lymph node metastasis. In general, evidence
of lymph node metastasis to lymph nodes
in the thoracic inlet, of multiple levels
of metastasis and of extranodal invasion
indicates further occult disease and contraindicates
surgery. For patients with nonsurgical
stage IIIA tumors and those in the stage
IIIB category, the T and N categories serve
as guides for structuring treatment plans,
most often radiotherapy, chemotherapy or
combined therapy. Treatment for stage IV
disease is usually palliative radiotherapy
or chemotherapy. The structure of new investigational
approaches and the evaluation of results
depends on reproducible classification
of the extent of disease in these patients.
When
clinical and surgical estimates of disease
extent are compared, errors in
clinical staging usually relate to an underestimate
of the T and N categories. Therefore, if
the extent of disease is questionable,
it is appropriate to classify to the higher
designation.
Staging for Small Cell Lung
Cancer
In patients with small cell carcinoma,
the anatomic extent of disease is a major
factor in the proportion of patients that
achieve the complete response required
for long term survival. Consistent and
reproducible TNM and stage classifications
are useful for this cell type as well as
for non-small cell lung cancer24. For example,
the selection of patients for treatment
programs involving adjuvant surgery depends
on the initial TNM and stage classifications
or the retreatment evaluations following
induction therapy.
Review of the literature
confirms that it is common for the terms "limited" and "extensive" disease
to be inconsistently applied to small cell
lung cancer. The use of these designations
defeats the purpose and utility of consistent,
reproducible classification, which is now,
and will continue to be useful in the mileau
of evolving cancer knowledge. The structure
of new treatment plans depends on the results
achieved for specific groups of patients
that are best described in terms of the
TNM and stage categories. |