ALERT!

This site is not optimized for Internet Explorer 8 (or older).

Please upgrade to a newer version of Internet Explorer or use an alternate browser such as Chrome or Firefox.

Evaluation of the Nonstapling Bullectomy by Manual Suturing for Young Men With Primary Spontaneous Pneumothorax

Thursday, November 14, 2024

Submitted by

Source

Source Name: Journal of Thoracic Disease

Author(s)

Kosuke Suzuki, Akihiko Kitami, Shinsaku Komiyama, Momoka Okada, Shinnosuke Takamiya, Shinichi Ohashi, Shugo Uematsu

This retrospective study evaluated using nonstapling bullectomy via manual suturing as an alternative to traditional staple bullectomy in reducing the recurrence rate of primary spontaneous pneumothorax (PSP) in young male patients. The authors utilized hybrid VATS (hVATS) with a one-port-one-window approach for manual suturing. The study included 259 male patients aged 25 years old or less. Blood loss, hospitalization duration, operative time, and postoperative recurrence were measured for staple bullectomy (S+) and manually sutured bullectomy (S−). The results showed longer mean operating times for the S- group, but less blood loss. The median hospitalization for both groups was four days, however, recurrence rates were lower in theS- group (7.1 percent versus 12.2 percent). Therefore, manual suturing as an alternative to staple bullectomy can potentially reduce PSP recurrence. 

Comments

I would view the conclusions of this study cautiously. This study statistically does not demonstrate that suture bullectomy reduces recurrent PTX versus staple bullectomy. Statistically (p>0.05) neither one is superior to the other for recurrence - both in patients younger and older than 20 years old. Because of how statistics work - it's not fair to use terms like potentially, and unfortunately, the original article more egregiously misinterprets the study's findings and concludes 'beneficial in reducing recurrent PSP'. This study does not demonstrate in anyway a differences for suture bullectomy other than a reduction of 0.5ml of blood loss per case (p=0.003) and an increase in operative time of suturing of 18 minutes (p<0.001). I can tell you which is more clinically relevant for me.

Add comment

Log in or register to post comments